CSAIS
Transparency

How to check the evidence behind each incident, where the news comes from, and how close the machine and the public come to institution decisions.

Institution portal

Flow comparison D1–D4

How close the machine (D1) and the public survey (D2) come to institution statements (D3) and official records (D4). The pipeline recomputes these numbers daily from each flow's latest snapshot.

computed 7 Oct, 08:19 WIB

Coverage

D1 · Machine44,245incidents
D2 · Public survey280.063% of D1
D3 · Institution210.047% of D1
D4 · Official record180.041% of D1

Shared conclusion

one conclusion per flow; the last column compares the certain ones with D4
HappenedHoaxNot yet certainSame as D4
D1 · Machine––––n=0
D2 · Public survey––––n=0
D3 · Institution––––n=0
D4 · Official record––––

Machine accuracy against official records

D1 against confirmed D4 records, per field
FieldPrecisionRecallF1n
Attack type1.001.001.00n=8
Victim0.000.00–n=1
Actor1.001.001.00n=1
Event date1.001.001.00n=2
Location1.001.001.00n=5

Review accuracy against official records

whether public (D2) and institution (D3) reviews agree with D4
FieldD2 · Public surveyD3 · Institution
Attack type1.00n=3–n=0
Victim0.00n=11.00n=1
Actor1.00n=1–n=0
Event date1.00n=2–n=0
Location1.00n=3–n=0

Public and institution agreement

FieldAgreeKappan
Attack type––n=0
Victim0.0%0.00n=1
Actor––n=0
Event date––n=0
Location––n=0

Speed

median hours from the first article to the flow's first output
Median hoursn
D1 · Machine13.8n=2,053
D2 · Public survey–n=0
D3 · Institution–n=0
D4 · Official record–n=0

Hoaxes that slipped through

n
Refuted by institutions (D4)7n=18
Passed the machine (high/medium trust)3n=7
Passed the public (survey matches)4n=7

Preventive steps

n
Overlap of D1 and D4 steps (Jaccard)–n=0
D4 records adding steps beyond D1–n=0
Overlap of D1 and D4 literacy audiences (Jaccard)–n=0
Overlap of D1 and D4 literacy topics (Jaccard)–n=0

Selection bias

D1 trust levels: all incidents versus those that reached D4
All incidentsReached D4
high trust1.2%6.7%
medium trust7.8%26.7%
low trust91.0%66.7%
not scored0.0%0.0%

– means no data yet; n is the number of incidents or fields counted. See the per-incident comparison on each incident's detail page.